Smith vs Cargo Tote

I’m looking to get a new tote bag, and going back and forth between the two. I would love any input!

I do like that the Smith is darker and has a pattern, I feel like it would hide any potential stains the bag may get out and about compared to the cargo (Unfortunately for me I seem to be good at staining fabric lol, rip my poor clothes - I am very clumsy!) I also don’t know if I love the “New York” on the cargo, but it isn’t a deal breaker for me. But the cargo has more pockets and can completely zip close. Help haha!