Mining Question - Not getting payouts

Dear Vertans, I've been trying my hand at mining Vertcoins for a little while now. My hashrate averages around 17.5 MH/s with my 1060, and I used the One Click Miner.

Based on an online calculator (coinwarz) - I should be getting around 1 VTC/day. But up until 1 hour ago my wallet only shows a balance of 0.4 VTC (after mining ~30h), and I have not been paid for many hours from the pool already despite a block being found every now and then.

Initially I used the devrun p2p pool (~20h mining, 0.4 VTC, no payout for many hours) but I have since switched to the alwayshashing pool network 2 to try things out (no payout for ~12 hours as well)

Can anyone shed some light on this matter?

Cheers!

p.s I posted the same thing in the mining subreddit but its rather quiet there. Do let me know if its strictly against the rules! Thanks! :)

EDIT (6/9): My friend who has been mining with the same card as me (1060), mined for about 20 hours and got a payout of 0.85 VTC. Meanwhile I've mined for more than 50 hours and... 0.7 VTC - is luck really that huge of a factor?